
Marine Fights Discharge After Assault Report
PHOTO CAPTION: Marines participate in physical fitness testing. A Marine who reported being sexually assaulted by a Navy doctor was later discharged following a dispute over her pull-up score. She is seeking to return to service. (Illustrative file photo; credit and date to be confirmed.)
A Marine who reported being sexually assaulted by a Navy doctor was later discharged from the service following a dispute over how many pull-ups she completed during a physical fitness test.
She says she completed 12. The sergeant overseeing the test said she completed five.
Here's what makes the dispute unusual: even five pull-ups would have been enough for her to pass.
Now, after receiving an honorable discharge in October 2026 with misconduct listed as the reason for separation, she is fighting to get her military career back.
The case was detailed in a November 17 investigation by The War Horse, which reviewed hundreds of pages of military records and interviewed the Marine, her attorney, and others familiar with the case.
A Report That Changed Her Military Career
The Marine, identified only as Elizabeth to protect her privacy, was attending the Marine Corps' Basic School in Quantico, Virginia, when she visited a Navy doctor in the fall of 2023.
She had been experiencing nerve pain following a car accident.
According to Elizabeth, the doctor asked a Navy corpsman to leave the examination room and then touched her inappropriately.
She reported the alleged assault, and the Naval Criminal Investigative Service opened an investigation the following day.
The investigation lasted seven months. NCIS ultimately closed the case, citing insufficient evidence to establish probable cause. The doctor was not charged.
Elizabeth says her treatment at the Basic School changed after she filed the report. She alleges instructors refused to coach her and that she was prohibited from entering the building where her victim advocate worked.
Those allegations are part of a larger dispute over whether she experienced retaliation for coming forward.
The Disputed Fitness Test
In August 2024, Elizabeth took a Marine Corps physical fitness test.
She recorded 12 pull-ups, a number she had previously achieved on other tests, according to military records reviewed by The War Horse.
But the sergeant who supervised the event said she had completed only five.
Two weeks later, Elizabeth learned she was being investigated for allegedly falsifying her score.
The disagreement wasn't over whether she had passed. The lower count would still have met the required standard.
The issue was whether she had knowingly reported a score higher than the number of repetitions actually completed.
Elizabeth denied intentionally misreporting her performance.
She also said other Marines in her unit were allowed to retake their tests, while she was denied the same opportunity.
Her attorney, Ruth Cresenzo, a former Army National Guard judge advocate, argues that allowing a retest could have prevented the situation from escalating.
Instead, Elizabeth received disciplinary counseling, and her commander recommended administrative separation.
An Honorable Discharge With a Misconduct Designation
Elizabeth appealed the decision and received support from current and former service members.
The War Horse reviewed 16 letters recommending that she be retained.
Because she had served fewer than six years and was not facing an other-than-honorable discharge, she was not entitled to an administrative separation board hearing under the applicable rules.
In September 2026, she learned her request for a board hearing would not be granted.
She was honorably discharged the following month.
But her DD-214 listed misconduct involving a serious offense as the reason for separation.
That distinction matters. Although her discharge characterization was honorable, the recorded reason for separation could still affect how her service is viewed.
Elizabeth and her attorney believe the disciplinary proceedings were retaliation for reporting the alleged assault. That claim has not been established by an independent finding.
She Still Wants to Be a Marine
Elizabeth's case is part of a broader investigation by The War Horse into service members who faced administrative separation after reporting sexual assault.
The newsroom obtained records showing that at least 30 Marines were administratively discharged within two years of reporting sexual assault over a five-year period.
Those records do not establish that every separation was retaliatory or improper.
The Marine Corps has an obligation to enforce fitness standards, maintain accurate records, and hold service members accountable for misconduct. Those responsibilities are not in dispute.
The question in Elizabeth's case is whether the disciplinary process was handled fairly and whether her earlier sexual assault report affected the decisions made about her career.
For now, she is trying to rebuild her life outside the service.
But she hasn't given up on the career she wanted.
Elizabeth plans to petition the Board for Correction of Naval Records, seeking reinstatement.
After everything that has happened, she still wants to wear the uniform.
(Source: OAF Nation)










